Leadership assessments are a large industry. Personality profiles. 360-degree reviews. Competency matrices. Behavioral inventories. Emotional intelligence scales. Most companies use at least one of them, and many use several.
They measure things that are real. Personality traits exist. Behaviors are observable. Feedback from peers is meaningful. But they measure around the thing that actually determines whether a leader is effective, not the thing itself.
I have watched high-scoring leaders fail and low-scoring leaders produce results, for close to thirty years. The assessments were accurate about what they measured. They were pointed at the layer above the one that determines results.
The layer most assessments measure
Traditional assessments answer three kinds of questions.
Who is this person? Personality inventories tell you what the leader tends to prefer, how they process information, what energizes them, what drains them. Useful for self-awareness. Not predictive of results.
How do they behave? 360-degree reviews tell you how the leader is perceived by peers, direct reports, and their boss. Useful for identifying blind spots. Also filtered through the biases of everyone answering.
What competencies do they have? Competency matrices tell you what the leader can do, in principle. Useful for hiring and promotion decisions. Not the same as what they actually do when the pressure is on.
Each of these has a place. None of them, on its own, tells you whether this leader will produce results in the circumstances they are actually inside.
The layer that predicts results
The layer that predicts results is what the leader does with the agreements between people on their team.
Every organizational outcome is the product of a network of agreements. Requests made. Commitments accepted. Work delivered, delivered late, renegotiated, or dropped without a conversation. The leader’s job, in practice, is to make that network work.
A leader can score high on every personality dimension and low on this layer. That leader will look impressive in the interview and produce inconsistent results in the role. A leader can score modestly on personality and high on this layer. That leader will produce results year after year, sometimes quietly, sometimes to the surprise of their assessors.
Effectiveness is not who the leader is. It is what happens between the leader and the people around them.
Five factors that actually predict leadership effectiveness
If you want to assess a leader in a way that predicts results, look at five things.
1. Do they make specific requests? Watch how they hand out work. “See if you can look into this” is not a request. “Send me a written recommendation by Friday, including the two options you considered and why you did not choose the second” is a request. Leaders who do this well produce results consistently. Leaders who leave requests vague produce inconsistent results, no matter what they score on other dimensions.
2. Do they insist on real commitments? After a request, does the leader require a spoken commitment, or accept a nod? “Sure” is not a commitment. “Yes, I will do that by Friday” is. Effective leaders will not move past the request until the commitment is explicit.
3. Do they renegotiate before deadlines, not after? When something is not going to be delivered on time, does the leader teach their people to say so early, or do they discover it at the deadline? This is a practice, not a personality trait. It can be observed. It predicts everything downstream.
4. Do they separate facts from interpretation? In a difficult moment, can the leader distinguish what actually happened from what they concluded it meant? Leaders who cannot do this react to interpretations as if they were facts, and their teams learn to work around them. Leaders who can do this consistently make decisions that hold up.
5. Do they repair broken agreements, or let them accumulate? No agreement is kept perfectly, over time, in a real organization. The question is what the leader does when one breaks. Repair, or resentment. Effective leaders repair.
Notice what is on this list and what is not. Charisma is not on it. Confidence is not on it. Strategic thinking is not on it. Those things matter, but they do not determine effectiveness. What happens in the agreements does.
Why this is hard to assess with existing tools
Most assessments cannot see this layer, because they were built to measure something else. Personality profiles ask the leader about themselves. 360s ask people about the leader. Neither asks the question the layer actually turns on: what happens in the space between the leader and the people they work with, when a request is made, a commitment is given, and a deadline arrives?
To assess that, you have to look at the leader in the actual circumstance. Not the leader in an interview. Not the leader as their peers describe them. The leader on a Tuesday morning when a commitment slipped and a customer is upset.
This is why we built our evaluations the way we did. The PACT™ Leadership Assessment starts with actual situations. The LIFE Journey Evaluation™ goes deeper into how the leader operates across the domains their work depends on. Both look at the layer that predicts results, not the layers that are easier to measure.
What to do with an assessment you already have
If your company already runs one of the standard tools, keep using it. Use it for what it is good at. Personality profiles help with self-awareness. 360s help with blind spots. Competency matrices help with hiring.
Then add the five questions above. Ask them of the leaders on your team. If the answers are unclear, work on the layer directly, through the Leaders Edge Path™ or through the Network of Agreements™ practices. That is where effectiveness is actually made.
Sandor Kovacs CEO and Co-Founder, DorWay™
FAQ
What is the single most predictive factor for leadership effectiveness?
The ability to make specific requests, receive real commitments, and repair broken agreements. All three are practices, not traits.
Do personality assessments predict leadership success?
They predict some aspects of style. They do not predict results. Style and results are related, but they are not the same thing.
Can leadership effectiveness be trained?
The practices that produce it can be trained. The willingness to practice them cannot. That decision is the leader’s.
