Coaching KPIs are the specific, trackable indicators that show whether a coaching program is changing how leaders work, not just whether sessions are happening. The most useful set mixes leading indicators (what coachees do between sessions) with lagging indicators (results that follow, such as team retention or goal delivery).
There is a difference between a coaching program that is running and one that is working. Running means coaches are matched, sessions happen, and nobody complains. Working means people operate differently at work as a result. The KPIs below are built to tell those two states apart.
Activity metrics versus effectiveness metrics
Vendor dashboards usually report activity: sessions held, hours delivered, satisfaction ratings. These are useful for managing the program, but they do not show impact. Effectiveness metrics track behavior and results.
| KPI | Type | What it tells you | How to collect it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Session attendance and completion | Activity | The program is running | Coach or platform reports |
| Coachee satisfaction | Activity | Coach fit and relevance | Short pulse survey |
| Share of sessions on real work situations | Leading | Coaching is touching actual work | Coach session notes (category only) |
| Practices committed and attempted | Leading | Coachees are trying new behavior | Coachee log or coach tracking |
| Goal attainment rating | Behavior | Progress on agreed goals | Coach, coachee, and manager rating |
| Manager-observed change | Behavior | Change is visible at work | Two or three structured questions |
| 360 or assessment score change | Behavior | Colleagues see the difference | Pre and post assessment |
| Commitments kept by the coachee’s team | Results | Execution is improving | Project or meeting records |
| Team retention and engagement | Results | The leader’s team is more stable | HR systems, engagement survey |
| Promotion readiness or internal moves | Results | Bench strength is growing | Talent review |
Leading indicators: signs the program is working early
These show up within weeks and predict whether later results will come.
- Coachees bring real situations. If sessions run mostly on hypotheticals or general reflection, the program is not touching where change happens.
- Coachees leave with a specific practice. Not “think about what we discussed,” but something concrete, such as asking a team member in the next one-on-one what they believe the agreement is.
- Coachees report back. Success or failure both count. What matters is that the practice was attempted and examined.
- Managers notice differences. Ask the coachee’s manager, briefly, whether they see anything different. If the answer is consistently “not really” after two or three months, take note.
Lagging indicators: results that follow
Lagging indicators take months and are influenced by many factors, so treat them as supporting evidence. The Kirkpatrick Model calls this level “results”: whether the outcomes the initiative was meant to produce actually occur. Pick one or two that the coachee’s role genuinely influences, such as delivery against team commitments or voluntary turnover on the team, and track them against a baseline.
Warning signs that a program is running but not working
- High satisfaction scores with no change in manager observations.
- Goals that are still vague at the midpoint.
- Coachees who cannot name a single practice they are working on.
- Reports that list hours delivered but say nothing about behavior.
- Rescheduled sessions becoming the norm.
Many of these trace back to unclear agreements between coachee, coach, and manager. DorWay treats accountability as making, keeping, and openly renegotiating commitments, and that gives you a simple test: are coachees making specific commitments and reporting on whether they kept them?
How to set benchmarks for your coaching KPIs
Published industry benchmarks for coaching vary widely in method and are rarely comparable to your program. Your own baseline is more useful. Set targets this way:
- Measure the baseline for each KPI before coaching starts.
- Run a first cohort and record the results without targets.
- Set targets for the next cohort based on what the first one achieved.
- Where possible, compare coached leaders with a similar uncoached group.
For how these KPIs feed a full cohort report, see our guide to coaching program evaluation. For data-collection methods, see measuring coaching effectiveness.
Choosing the right KPIs for your program
Pick no more than six: one or two activity metrics to manage the program, two leading indicators, and two behavior or results indicators. Make sure each one is linked to a stated program goal. A repeatable assessment such as the PACT™ Leadership Assessment can supply the behavior measure, and DorWay’s eight leadership practices give coaches a shared vocabulary for what practices to track.
FAQ
What are the key performance indicators for coaching?
The most useful coaching KPIs are goal attainment, manager-observed behavior change, change in 360 or assessment scores, practices attempted between sessions, and one or two business results such as team retention.
How do you know if coaching is working?
Coachees bring real work situations, leave each session with a specific practice, report back on it, and their managers notice a difference within a few months.
Are satisfaction scores a good coaching KPI?
They are useful for spotting poor coach matches, but they do not show whether behavior changed. Pair them with behavior and results indicators.
How many KPIs should a coaching program track?
Around four to six. More than that tends to produce reports nobody reads and data nobody acts on.
