Upward feedback is structured input that employees give about their direct manager or team leader, usually through a short, anonymous survey about specific leadership behaviors. It shows leaders how their management habits are experienced by the people they lead, which is information they rarely get any other way.
It is simpler than a full 360, which also includes peers and the leader’s own manager. That simplicity is a strength: upward feedback can be run more often, with fewer questions, and focused on the day-to-day behaviors that shape a team’s experience.
Does upward feedback improve leadership?
There is good evidence it can, under the right conditions. In a study of 238 managers, Smither and colleagues (1995) found that managers who started with low or moderate ratings from their direct reports improved over the following six months, and the improvement could not be explained by regression to the mean alone. A later meta-analysis of multisource feedback by Smither, London, and Reilly (2005) found that average improvement was generally small, but larger when leaders set goals and took action, and that managers who discussed their feedback with their direct reports improved more than those who did not.
The lesson is that the survey itself does little. What leaders do with the results determines whether anything changes.
What to ask in an upward feedback survey
Keep it to ten to fifteen items about observable behavior, rated on a consistent scale, plus one or two open questions.
| Area | Sample item |
|---|---|
| Clarity | My manager makes it clear what is expected of me, by when. |
| Agreements | When my manager asks for something, we agree on who does what and by when. |
| Reliability | My manager does what they say they will do. |
| Renegotiation | When plans change, my manager tells me early and we reset the commitment together. |
| Feedback | I get specific feedback that helps me improve. |
| Development | My manager helps me build skills for my next step. |
| Safety | I can raise a problem or disagree without negative consequences. |
| Support | My manager removes obstacles that slow our team down. |
| Open question | What is one thing my manager should start, stop, or continue doing? |
Several items focus on agreements, by design. DorWay sees organizations as a Network of Agreements™: most breakdowns between managers and teams, from missed deadlines to quiet frustration, start with requests that were never specific enough to keep. Direct reports experience these agreements every day, which makes them the best judges of how well a manager handles them. Our page on team agreements explains what specific looks like.
How to run upward feedback well
- Protect anonymity. Report results only when at least three or four people respond, and never show individual answers.
- Explain the purpose. Tell employees it is for development and how results will be used.
- Keep it separate from pay at first. Linking upward ratings to compensation tends to make answers less candid and invites lobbying.
- Debrief every leader. A short session with HR or a coach helps leaders read results without defensiveness.
- Ask leaders to share back. Leaders thank the team, name one or two things they will work on, and ask for help noticing progress. This step is where most of the improvement comes from.
- Repeat it. Every six to twelve months, with the same items, so trends are visible.
Upward feedback vs. 360 feedback vs. engagement surveys
- Upward feedback: direct reports only, about one manager. Short, frequent, focused on management habits.
- 360 feedback: adds peers, the leader’s manager, and self-ratings. Broader view, more effort, usually annual.
- Engagement survey: about the whole employee experience. Can show team-level patterns but does not give a manager specific behavioral feedback.
Upward feedback also feeds well into a formal team leader evaluation and into broader leadership competency assessment.
Common problems
- Teams too small for anonymity. Combine small teams or use a facilitated conversation instead.
- Leaders hunting for who said what. Address this directly in training; it destroys trust quickly.
- No visible action. If employees see nothing change, response rates and candor fall in the next round.
- Too many items. Long surveys produce careless answers.
For a commitment-focused diagnostic that complements upward feedback, see the PACT™ Leadership Assessment. Our page on accountability in leadership describes the behaviors many upward feedback items measure.
FAQ
What is upward feedback?
It is feedback employees give about their manager, usually through a short anonymous survey on specific leadership behaviors such as clarity, follow-through, feedback, and support.
What are examples of upward feedback questions?
“My manager makes it clear what is expected of me,” “My manager does what they say they will do,” “I get specific feedback that helps me improve,” and “What should my manager start, stop, or continue doing?”
Should upward feedback be anonymous?
In most organizations, yes. Anonymity increases candor. Results should only be reported for groups large enough that individuals cannot be identified.
How often should upward feedback be collected?
Every six to twelve months is common. Running it more often works only if leaders act visibly on each round.
