Coaching evaluation questions are the survey and interview questions used to judge whether a coaching engagement worked: whether the coachee reached their goals, whether others noticed a change in behavior, and whether the coaching relationship itself was effective. The best questions ask about specific, observable change rather than general satisfaction.
Below are 30 ready-to-use questions grouped by respondent and timing, plus guidance on scales, timing, and turning answers into evidence.
Who to ask, and when
A single end-of-engagement satisfaction survey tells you little. A better approach asks three groups at three points:
| Respondent | Start | Midpoint | End and 90 days later |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coachee | Goals, baseline self-rating | Relationship quality, progress | Goal attainment, behavior change, what helped |
| Coachee’s manager | Expected changes, baseline rating | Early signs of change | Observed change, business effect |
| Direct reports or peers | Short baseline on target behaviors | Optional | Same items repeated |
| Program sponsor (HR or L&D) | Objectives for the coaching program | Utilization, issues | Pattern across engagements |
The 90-day follow-up after coaching ends is the most valuable and the most often skipped. It shows whether change lasted without the coach.
Questions for the coachee
At the start
- What are the two or three things you most want to be different at the end of this coaching?
- How would someone who works with you every day notice that change?
- On a scale of 1 to 10, where are you today on each goal?
At the midpoint
- How much do you trust your coach to be honest with you? (1 to 5)
- How clear are you about the goals you and your coach agreed? (1 to 5)
- What have you done differently at work since coaching began? Give one example.
- What would make the remaining sessions more useful?
At the end and 90 days later
- On a scale of 1 to 10, where are you now on each original goal?
- What specific behavior have you changed? Describe a recent situation where you used it.
- What commitments did you make during coaching, and which have you kept?
- What got in the way of applying what you worked on?
- What would you lose if you stopped doing what you learned?
- Would you recommend this coach to a colleague facing a similar challenge? Why or why not?
Questions about the coaching relationship
The relationship is one of the strongest predictors of outcomes. A meta-analysis by Grassmann, Schölmerich and Schermuly (2020) found a moderate, consistent relationship (r = .41) between working alliance quality and coaching outcomes across 3,563 coaching processes. Ask about it directly:
- My coach and I agree on what I am working toward. (1 to 5)
- My coach and I agree on how we are working. (1 to 5)
- I feel my coach understands my situation. (1 to 5)
- My coach challenges me when I need it. (1 to 5)
Low midpoint scores on these items are a reason to address the relationship, or change coaches, before the engagement ends.
Questions for the coachee’s manager
- What change did you hope coaching would produce?
- How often do you now see that change? (Never, sometimes, often, consistently)
- Describe one recent situation where you saw a difference.
- How has this person’s effect on their team changed?
- How reliably does this person now keep the commitments they make? (1 to 5)
- What still needs to improve?
Questions for direct reports or peers
Keep these to five or six items about the coachee’s target behaviors, asked at the start and repeated at the end. For example:
- This person is clear about what they expect from me and by when.
- This person follows through on what they say they will do.
- When plans change, this person tells me early.
- I can raise problems with this person without hesitation.
- Over the last three months, I have noticed a change in how this person leads. (Yes or no, with an example)
Questions for the program sponsor
- Across engagements, which goals were most and least often achieved, and why?
- What patterns in the coachees’ work environment helped or blocked change?
How to turn answers into evidence
- Compare before and after on the same items, from the same respondents.
- Weight others’ ratings over self-ratings. Change that only the coachee sees is weak evidence.
- Collect examples. Specific stories make numbers credible to sponsors.
- Look at commitments. Questions 10 and 22 track whether coaching produced kept commitments, which is the practical test of accountability. DorWay’s view is that organizations are a Network of Agreements™, so changes in how a leader makes and keeps agreements are often the clearest sign coaching worked.
For whether coaching gains last after the engagement ends, see long-term effects of coaching. For different ways coaches work with clients, see directive vs non-directive coaching. A quick, free starting point on agreements and trust is the PACT™ Leadership Assessment.
FAQ
What questions should be asked to evaluate coaching?
Ask the coachee about goal progress and specific behavior changes, ask their manager and colleagues what they have observed, and ask about the coaching relationship itself. Repeat the key items 90 days after coaching ends.
How do you write a coaching feedback survey?
Keep it short, use the same items before and after, focus on observable behaviors, use a consistent 1 to 5 scale, and include one open question asking for a specific example.
When should you evaluate a coaching engagement?
At the start to set a baseline, at the midpoint to check the relationship and progress, at the end, and again around 90 days later to see whether change lasted.
Should the coach see the evaluation results?
Yes, in most cases. Relationship scores and manager observations help the coach adjust. Agree on confidentiality rules with the coachee before the engagement starts.
